![]() |
![]() |
J. Electromagn. Eng. Sci > Volume 21(5); 2021 > Article |
|
Study | Size (mm3) | Notch bands covered (GHz) | Technique | Frequency range (GHz) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Abdollahvand et al. [1] | 20 × 18 × 1.86 |
3.3–3.8 5.1–6 |
Etching I-shaped slots on the ground plane and pair of Γ-shaped stubs | 2.8–11.8 |
Zhang et al. [2] | 47 × 37 × 1.5 | 5.1–6.1 | Segmenting a circular patch into three parts | 2.8–13.5 |
Taheri et al. [3] | 23 × 28 × 0.8 | At 3.5 and 5.8 | L-shaped with quarter wavelength stubs and slot with octagonal shape | 3.1–11 |
Nguyen et al. [4] | 25 × 29 × 0.8 |
3.3–3.7 5.15–5.825 7.25–7.75 |
A straight open-ended quarter wavelength slot and semi-circular half-wavelength cut | 3–11 |
Lee et al. [5] | 29.38 × 28.25 × 0.508 | 5.01–6.19 | λ/4 slotted line resonator and stub loaded circular radiating patch | 2.95–10.75 |
Li et al. [6] | 38.5 × 46.4 × 1 |
5–5.5 7.2–7.6 |
Etching one quasi complementary SRR in feed line and TM-MTM | 2–12.5 |
Yang et al. [7] | 25 × 30 × 0.762 | NA | Coplanar slot line transition | 3.1–10.6 |
Tang et al. [8] | 39 × 39 × 1.6 |
3.25–3.75 5.08–5.9 7.06–7.95 |
Multi slot and multi-slit | 2.3–13.75 |
Tu et al. [9] | 35 × 30 × 0.8 | 5.2–6 | Pair of stubs and slits | 2.78–12.3 |
Siddiqui et al. [10] | 307.4 × 282 × 1.575 | At 2.55 and 3.18 | Square split-ring resonators | 0–9 |
Chuamg et al. [11] | 27.6 × 30 × 0.4 | 5.15–5.95 | Non-uniform short-circuited stub | 2.4–11 |
Kang et al. [12] | 38.5 × 38.5 × 1.6 | 5.03–5.97 | L-shaped slits | 3.08–11.8 |
Jiang and Che [13] | 59 × 73 × 0.8 |
3.3–4 5.05–5.9 |
U-shaped parasitic strips with T-shaped stub | 2.8–11 |
Kingsly et al. [14] | 30 × 25 × 1.57 |
3.31–3.57 5.26–5.45 5.78–5.91 |
J-shaped and asymmetric T-shaped with open-ended stub | 3.1–10.6 |
Huang et al. [15] | 64 × 64 × 0.8 | 5–6 | Octagonal shaped slot | 3–11 |
Gao et al. [17] | 48 × 48 × 0.8 | 5.1–6 | Two SRR slots on the radiator with 45° and two stair-cases shaped radiating element | 2.5–12 |
Sung [18] | 33 × 25 × 1.14 |
3.37–3.8 4.26–5.85 5.1–6 |
H-shaped resonator | 3.04–11.3 |
Li et al. [20] | 26 × 26 × 0.762 |
5.3–5.8 7.85–8.55 |
Split-ring resonator | 2.9–11.6 |
Liu and Tu [21] | 44 × 44 × 1.6 | 5.10–5.95 | U-shaped feed line and slot | 2.95–10.8 |
Sarkar et al. [22] | 35 × 19 × 1.6 |
3.3–3.8 5.15–5.65 7.9–8.4 |
Elliptical single complementary split-ring resonators | 2.21–11.71 |
Vendik et al. [23] | 50 × 50 × 1.52 | At 3.5, 5.8, 7.5 | Electric ring resonator incorporated into the CPW | 2.5–12 |
Chandel et al. [25] | 18 × 34 × 1.6 |
5.1–5.8 6.7–7.1 |
Inverted L-shaped slits | 2.93–20 |
Nguyen et al. [26] | 19 × 24 × 1.2 |
3.3–3.7 5.15–5.825 7.25–7.75 |
Open-ended quarter wavelength slots | 2.45–10.65 |
Azim et al. [27] | 29 × 20.5 × 1.6 | At 3.5 and 5.5 | Dual-band notch achieved by the tri-arm resonator | 2.98–10.76 |
Sung [28] | 25 × 33 × 0.3 |
3.41–3.68 5.37–6.01 |
Two short circuits folded stepped impedance resonator | 3.07–10.61 |
Rehman and Alkanhal [29] | 80 × 70 × 1.54 |
2.15–2.65 3–3.7 5.45–5.98 8–8.68 |
Deflection slots | 1.5–12 |
Jiang et al. [30] | 200 × 200 × 1 |
0.72–2.96 3.25–3.59 5.06–6.21 |
MIMO array 3D U-slot cut | 0.5–7 |
Zhang et al. [31] | 19 × 19 × 0.6 |
2.4–2.5 5–10 |
Stub triangular shorted structure & two parasitic metallic pins | 2.96–14.5 |
Pan and Dong [32] | 80 × 80 × 0.5 | NA | Two tapered slots | 2.94–10.06 |
Proposed work | 32 × 30 × 1.6 |
3.1–3.6 4.92–6.12 7.5–8.4 10.2–11 |
Inserting L-shaped slots in radiating patch and H and RSRR are arranged near to feed line. | 2.9–14.5 |
![]() |
![]() |